Appearance
Route
Route answers one question for each accepted possible constraint: what is the cheapest change that can work? Code walks a fixed ladder of changes and gives each one a verdict with reasons. A person chooses. DutyGraph does not run the change.
Route lives in Opportunities: the Changes tab, the Map (opened from Changes) and What AI can do today (opened from a change's AI fit).
INFO
No AI call makes a verdict, a fit, a value or an option order in Route. Code makes each one from the Company Repo. The same Repo gives the same answer.
Before you start
Route shows a card only for an accepted possible constraint. If Changes says "Accept a possible constraint in Strategy first", open Opportunities › Possible constraints and accept one with an owner. See Outcomes and Strategy.
Route reads only the Task Cards that the possible constraint cites as evidence. It never routes the counter-evidence.
How Route reasons
Step 1
Type the constraint
Code names what the work waits for:
| Type | The work waits for |
|---|---|
| A · Capacity at a step | a resource's hours |
| B · Decision or approval latency | a named decider's attention |
| C · Policy: a rule to meet | a date, a signature or a form |
| D · Information or handoff quality | a missing or wrong input from another team |
| E · One person's skill or time | one person's time or knowledge |
| F · Demand | orders that do not arrive (sent back to Strategy, not routed) |
| G · Supplier or outside party | a party outside the company |
When nobody owns a cited Task Card, the type is Owner not agreed. The first change is to name the owner, and no AI change is offered until then.
Step 2
Walk the ladder, cheapest first
The ladder has 9 rungs. The type sets the order in which rungs are tried.
| Rung | Change | Who carries it out |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | No change | Nobody |
| 1 | Remove the work | People |
| 2 | Decision rule or owner | People |
| 3 | Process change | People |
| 4 | Training or a backup | People |
| 5 | Setting in a system the company has | The company's existing software |
| 6 | Automation with no AI | Software |
| 7 | AI: assist, draft, recommend or an agent | An AI tool or an agent, with a person as set by its AI mode |
| 8 | Hiring or outsourcing | A new hire or an outside vendor, decided with the client |
Each rung gets one verdict:
| Verdict | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Chosen by rule | The first rung, in the type's order, that fits. |
| Fits | It can work, but it is not the first that fits. |
| Does not fit | A recorded fact rules it out. The reason names the file. |
| Not enough data | A number or fact is Not found. The row names the person to ask. |
| Not proposed | DutyGraph does not offer it here, for example AI on "People only" work. |
Every reason has a chip for each Repo file it cites. When code cannot choose yet, the card says Answer the asks first or Test first.
Step 3
Check the AI fit
For each Task Card, Route shows a fit profile: input form, rule or judgment steps, exceptions, volume, system access, risk class, data sensitivity and whether the output can be checked. Each factor shows its value and evidence word, or Not found. It is a profile, never a score.
Route matches the profile against the 12 patterns in What AI can do today. Automation with no AI is listed above every AI pattern for rule-based work with structured inputs. Mostly physical work never routes to AI.
Step 4
Size the value in hours
Value is a range of hours a month, and nothing else:
hours in scope a month = runs a month × minutes per run ÷ 60
Each input shows its evidence word and file. A missing input makes the value Not found, never 0, and drafts an ask. The card says: "Hours in scope. This is the work that the change can touch. It is not a saving." Route shows no money, no savings and no return on investment (ROI).
Step 5
Plan the proof
Each card has a Proof plan: baseline, pilot, window, stop rule and a guardrail measure. The baseline and the pilot each need at least 10 runs over at least 14 days. Code sets the result word in Outcomes.
Choose and record the change
- Open a row on Changes to open its route card.
- Do this before you accept: in Proof plan, select Start the baseline… and record readings.
- Select Accept the route…. The rung chosen by rule is selected.
- To choose another rung, write a reason. The card then shows "Chosen by" your name and the reason.
- Choose the owner of the change. Write the prediction: low, high, unit and direction.
- Write the guardrail, the window, the stop rule and the review date.
- Select the box, then Record the decision.
Accept writes the change, its measure and its guardrail measure. A card has one decision. To replace it, select Change the decision…. DutyGraph keeps the old record.
What happens next
| Chosen change | Next step |
|---|---|
| Rung 7, AI | Open in Agents to draft the agent. See Agent builder and manifests. |
| Rungs 5 and 6 | Export work order (draft): Markdown and JSON with the scope, steps, fit, ladder, systems, numbers, proof plan and gaps. |
| Rungs 1 to 4 | Record a decision rule. |
| Every card | Track in Outcomes. |
Fill the missing numbers
The numbers tray on Changes counts the numbers that are Not found. Select Draft asks to draft one ask per person. Nothing is sent until you send it from Discovery › Asks.
What AI can do today, and Refresh
What AI can do today is a curated library of 12 patterns, such as document extraction, record matching and drafting messages for review. Each shows when it fits, its failure modes, the person checks it needs and its pilot measures. Its reliability band is labelled "Assumption · DutyGraph curated" with a date. It is not a result for your company. An entry older than 90 days reads "Out of date · check again".
Refresh asks for your consent, then starts a research run on the company's research source. It searches only the patterns that fit this company and the systems the client confirmed. Each option needs a source URL and a date, and waits in review before it shows. Options show in three groups, in alphabetical order: a feature in a system the company has, a workflow tool, a product for this kind of work. DutyGraph does not rank vendors or choose a tool. On the sample companies, Refresh loads authored sample options with no web search and no AI call.
INFO
Status. Constraint typing, the ladder and its verdicts, the fit profile, the 12-pattern library, the hours value, the proof plan, Accept, Change the decision, the work order draft export, the Map, Refresh, Present slides and print are Built. The sample companies show authored sample numbers and options, with no AI call. Money values, AI wording of reasons, vendor names in the library and hiring or outsourcing as an active route are Planned.
Source: gitbook/product/opportunities/route.md in the DutyGraph repository.